Chorus and Verse
Larry Kirwan
Chorus and Verse Blog
Posted: April 10, 2012 03:06 pm (-05:00)
Larry Kirwan
Musician/Novelist/Activist - Leader of Black 47
Appointment with Mr. Yeats

How long since you heard a really great new CD?

I'm not talking about something with a couple of decent songs and a truckload of filler. I receive scores of those annually at SiriusXM – many with little thought or notion of originality.

And then you hear an album that floors you and renews your faith in artistry. An Appointment With Mr. Yeats by The Waterboys is such a work.

I've rarely liked Yeats set to music, and I know whereof I speak having tried it myself.

Yeats himself was apparently tone deaf although he obviously heard some stellar notes floating around inside his head. But it's a whole different ballgame getting them down on the page; perhaps that's why he never tried.

Yet what a poet he was! Every syllable is so sublimely calibrated; every poem finely balanced on some exacting fulcrum of taste and truth.

"Poetry should be as cold and passionate as the dawn," he demanded. The problem with such a dictum is that should he have written something of sadness or longing and a composer adds a dash more of the same, then the resultant song risks becoming maudlin and morose.

Mike Scott of The Waterboys avoids this temptation like the plague. For one thing he eschews all forms of the twee folkiness that has tainted so much of Yeats set to music.

Instead he uses a full palette of rock & roll that, dare I say it, not only adds to but often deepens our understanding of Yeats' perfection. Scott shakes the dust of a century from some poems with driving muscular beats, while others he caresses with fine sensitive musical fingers and coaxes forth elements that I had never before noticed.

At times he shouts, occasionally he whispers but even at his most animated there is an odd dispassion in his voice - he instinctively recognize that he must keep a distance for fear of sweeping Mister Yeats' intricate gossamer web of poetry off its inner fulcrum.

Yet he is rarely reverential. He repeats lines and unleashes structures long calcified by tradition and academic mustiness. My God, he even adds a bridge with some fine lyrics to Sweet Dancer that could send purists howling for the hills. Amazingly, if airwaves weren't so corporate controlled he'd have a hit single, for Dancer is as catchy as any Lady Gaga anthem.

And what of standards like Song of Wandering Aengus? Well it glides atop a graceful keyboard, anchored to a steady beat and augmented by an improvised flute on the outro that will keep you searching for your own glimmering girl long after you've located those fabled silver apples of the moon.

The Lake Isle of Inisfree is likewise a delight. Who would have dreamed that the bee-loud glade would shimmer to a restrained blues shuffle made heady by Steve Wickham's pyschedelic fiddling?

It wouldn't surprise me if Let The Earth Bear Witness becomes one of the great rallying cries for human rights. I wasn't familiar with this piece lifted from Yeats' play Cathleen Ní Houlihan but Scott transforms it into an elegy as riveting as it is haunting.

Despite its power I've always had mixed feelings about September 1913. Written at the height of the Dublin Lockout and printed in the Irish Times, I suppose I resented that the sacrifice of the workers led by James Connolly and Jim Larkin goes unmentioned while Yeats righteously rants against what he considers the greater calamities - the emergence of a new "greasy tilled" merchant class and the era's general crassness.

Be that as it may, who would have thought that "Romantic Ireland's dead and gone, it's with O'Leary in the Grave" would make one of the finest rock choruses Iíve heard in many the year.

I'd hold off writing this but given our own insipid times Appointment with Mr. Yeats is unlikely to get the decently funded American release it deserves. So, jump the gun, go to - and buy this revelatory CD. Believe me, I've only touched the surface; there's genius to be had within.

Larry Kirwan

Larry Kirwan is the leader, singer/guitarist and composer for the Irish-American rock band Black 47. Black 47 has released thirteen CDs for both major and independent labels. The band has appeared on Leno, Letterman and O'Brien and been profiled in most major magazines and newspapers in the US. Their album, Trouble in the Land, was recently voted the "top album of the decade" by readers of Bankers and Gangsters, Black 47's latest CD, was released in March 2010 by UFO Music.

Kirwan has also recorded Kilroy Was Here and Keltic Kids as solo efforts.

He has written twelve plays and musicals, five of which are collected in the book Mad Angels. Liverpool Fantasy, his best-known play, has been produced Off-Broadway and at the Dublin Theatre Festival. He has also written a novel version of Liverpool Fantasy (translated into Japanese, Spanish and Greek), a memoir - Green Suede Shoes - and Livin' in America, a collection of songs and stories. Rockin' The Bronx, his latest novel, was recently published in the US and UK/Ireland.

Kirwan hosts and produces Celtic Crush for SiriusXM Satellite Radio and writes a weekly column for the Irish Echo.

A political activist, he has long been involved in Irish and American causes.

He is currently working on a new novel about the aftermath of 9/11 and a musical with Thomas Keneally of Schindler's List fame.

Connect with Larry Kirwan on:
Black 47 Official Website Black 47 Official Website
Black 47 on Facebook Black 47 on Facebook
Black 47 on Twitter Black 47 on Twitter
©2012, Chorus and Verse
Recent Blogs By Larry Kirwan [ CLICK FOR FULL LIST ]
Culture Of Connectivity
Martin Hayes & Iarla Ó'Lionáird
Individual Versus Community
A Nun's Story
Gunfight at Rosie's Corral
Alexander Hamilton
Unlucky Green
Brian Mór - A Man You Don't Meet Every Day
Goin' To Kansas City
Staff Sergeant Robert Bales
US iTunes, App Store, iBookstore, and Mac App Store
US iTunes, App Store, iBookstore, and Mac App Store
Front Page
Content Archive
Contact Us
Chorus and Verse on LinkedIn